taikun.cloud

Taikun Logo

Taikun OCP Guide

Table of Contents

CPU models

Nova allows you to control the guest CPU model that is exposed to
instances. Use cases include:

  • To maximize performance of instances by exposing new host CPU
    features to the guest
  • To ensure a consistent default behavior across all machines,
    removing reliance on system defaults.

Important

The functionality described below is currently only supported by the
libvirt driver.

CPU modes

In libvirt, the CPU is specified by providing a base CPU model name
(which is a shorthand for a set of feature flags), a set of additional
feature flags, and the topology (sockets/cores/threads). The libvirt KVM
driver provides a number of standard CPU model names. These models are
defined in /usr/share/libvirt/cpu_map/*.xml. You can
inspect these files to determine which models are supported by your
local installation.

Two Compute configuration options in the libvirt group
of nova.conf define which type of CPU model is exposed to
the hypervisor when using KVM: libvirt.cpu_mode and libvirt.cpu_models.

The libvirt.cpu_mode option can take one of
the following values: none, host-passthrough,
host-model, and custom.

See Effective
Virtual CPU configuration in Nova
for a recorded presentation about
this topic.

Host model

If cpu_mode=host-model <libvirt.cpu_mode>,
the CPU model in /usr/share/libvirt/cpu_map/*.xml that most
closely matches the host and requests additional CPU flags to complete
the match. This CPU model has a number of advantages:

  • It provides almost all of the host CPU features to the guest, thus
    providing close to the maximum functionality and performance
    possible.
  • It auto-adds critical guest CPU flags for mitigation from certain
    security flaws, provided the CPU microcode, kernel, QEMU, and
    libvirt are all updated.
  • It computes live migration compatibility, with the caveat that live
    migration in both directions is not always possible.

In general, using host-model is a safe choice if your
compute node CPUs are largely identical. However, if your compute nodes
span multiple processor generations, you may be better advised to select
a custom CPU model.

The host-model CPU model is the default for the KVM
& QEMU hypervisors (libvirt.virt_type=kvm/qemu)

Note

As noted above, live migration is not always possible in both
directions when using host-model. During live migration,
the source CPU model definition is transferred to the destination host
as-is. This results in the migrated guest on the destination seeing
exactly the same CPU model as on source even if the destination compute
host is capable of providing more CPU features. However, shutting down
and restarting the guest on the may present different hardware to the
guest, as per the new capabilities of the destination compute.

Host passthrough

If cpu_mode=host-passthrough <libvirt.cpu_mode>,
libvirt tells KVM to pass through the host CPU with no modifications. In
comparison to host-model which simply matches feature
flags, host-passthrough ensures every last detail of the
host CPU is matched. This gives the best performance, and can be
important to some apps which check low level CPU details, but it comes
at a cost with respect to migration.

In host-passthrough mode, the guest can only be
live-migrated to a target host that matches the source host extremely
closely. This includes the physical CPU model and running microcode, and
may even include the running kernel. Use this mode only if your compute
nodes have a very large degree of homogeneity (i.e. substantially all of
your compute nodes use the exact same CPU generation and model), and you
make sure to only live-migrate between hosts with exactly matching
kernel versions. Failure to do so will result in an inability to support
any form of live migration.

Note

The reason for that it is necessary for the CPU microcode versions to
match is that hardware performance counters are exposed to an instance
and it is likely that they may vary between different CPU models. There
may also be other reasons due to security fixes for some hardware
security flaws being included in CPU microcode.

Custom

If cpu_mode=custom <libvirt.cpu_mode>,
you can explicitly specify an ordered list of supported named models
using the libvirt.cpu_models configuration
option. It is expected that the list is ordered so that the more common
and less advanced CPU models are listed earlier.

In selecting the custom mode, along with a libvirt.cpu_models that matches the
oldest of your compute node CPUs, you can ensure that live migration
between compute nodes will always be possible. However, you should
ensure that the libvirt.cpu_models you select passes
the correct CPU feature flags to the guest.

If you need to further tweak your CPU feature flags in the
custom mode, see CPU feature
flags
.

Note

If libvirt.cpu_models is configured, the
CPU models in the list needs to be compatible with the host CPU. Also,
if libvirt.cpu_model_extra_flags is
configured, all flags needs to be compatible with the host CPU. If
incompatible CPU models or flags are specified, nova service will raise
an error and fail to start.

None

If cpu_mode=none <libvirt.cpu_mode>,
libvirt does not specify a CPU model. Instead, the hypervisor chooses
the default model.

The none CPU model is the default for all non-KVM.QEMU
hypervisors. (libvirt.virt_type!=kvm/qemu)

CPU feature flags

18.0.0 (Rocky)

Regardless of your configured libvirt.cpu_mode, it is also possible
to selectively enable additional feature flags. This can be accomplished
using the libvirt.cpu_model_extra_flags config
option. For example, suppose you have configured a custom CPU model of
IvyBridge, which normally does not enable the
pcid feature flag, but you do want to pass
pcid into your guest instances. In this case, you could
configure the following in nova.conf to enable this
flag.

[libvirt]
cpu_mode = custom
cpu_models = IvyBridge
cpu_model_extra_flags = pcid

An end user can also specify required CPU features through traits.
When specified, the libvirt driver will select the first CPU model in
the libvirt.cpu_models list that can
provide the requested feature traits. If no CPU feature traits are
specified then the instance will be configured with the first CPU model
in the list.

Consider the following nova.conf:

[libvirt]
cpu_mode = custom
cpu_models = Penryn,IvyBridge,Haswell,Broadwell,Skylake-Client

These different CPU models support different feature flags and are
correctly configured in order of oldest (and therefore most widely
supported) to newest. If the user explicitly required the
avx and avx2 CPU features, the latter of which
is only found of Haswell-generation processors or newer, then they could
request them using the trait{group}:HW_CPU_X86_AVX and trait{group}:HW_CPU_X86_AVX2 flavor extra
specs. For example:

$ openstack flavor set $FLAVOR \
    --property trait:HW_CPU_X86_AVX=required \
    --property trait:HW_CPU_X86_AVX2=required

As Haswell is the first CPU model supporting both of
these CPU features, the instance would be configured with this
model.

Mitigation for MDS
(“Microarchitectural Data Sampling”) Security Flaws

In May 2019, four new microprocessor flaws, known as MDS
and also referred to as RIDL and
Fallout
or ZombieLoad,
were discovered. These flaws affect unpatched Nova compute nodes and
instances running on Intel x86_64 CPUs.

Resolution

To get mitigation for the said MDS security flaws, a new CPU flag,
md-clear, needs to be exposed to the Nova instances. This
can be done as follows.

  1. Update the following components to the versions from your Linux
    distribution that have fixes for the MDS flaws, on all compute nodes
    with Intel x86_64 CPUs:

    • microcode_ctl
    • kernel
    • qemu-system-x86
    • libvirt
  2. When using the libvirt driver, ensure that the CPU flag
    md-clear is exposed to the Nova instances. This can be done
    in one of three ways, depending on your configured CPU mode:

    1. libvirt.cpu_mode=host-model

      When using the host-model CPU mode, the
      md-clear CPU flag will be passed through to the Nova guests
      automatically.

      This mode is the default, when libvirt.virt_type=kvm|qemu is set in
      /etc/nova/nova-cpu.conf on compute nodes.

    2. libvirt.cpu_mode=host-passthrough

      When using the host-passthrough CPU mode, the
      md-clear CPU flag will be passed through to the Nova guests
      automatically.

    3. libvirt.cpu_mode=custom

      When using the custom CPU mode, you must
      explicitly enable the CPU flag md-clear to the
      Nova instances, in addition to the flags required for previous
      vulnerabilities, using the libvirt.cpu_model_extra_flags. For
      example:

      [libvirt]
      cpu_mode = custom
      cpu_models = IvyBridge
      cpu_model_extra_flags = spec-ctrl,ssbd,md-clear
  3. Reboot the compute node for the fixes to take effect.

    To minimize workload downtime, you may wish to live migrate all
    guests to another compute node first.

Once the above steps have been taken on every vulnerable compute node
in the deployment, each running guest in the cluster must be fully
powered down, and cold-booted (i.e. an explicit stop followed by a
start), in order to activate the new CPU models. This can be done by the
guest administrators at a time of their choosing.

Validation

After applying relevant updates, administrators can check the
kernel’s sysfs interface to see what mitigation is in
place, by running the following command on the host:

# cat /sys/devices/system/cpu/vulnerabilities/mds
Mitigation: Clear CPU buffers; SMT vulnerable

To unpack the message “Mitigation: Clear CPU buffers; SMT
vulnerable”:

  • Mitigation: Clear CPU buffers means you have the “CPU
    buffer clearing” mitigation enabled, which is mechanism to invoke a
    flush of various exploitable CPU buffers by invoking a CPU instruction
    called “VERW”.
  • SMT vulnerable means, depending on your workload, you
    may still be vulnerable to SMT-related problems. You need to evaluate
    whether your workloads need SMT (also called “Hyper-Threading”) to be
    disabled or not. Refer to the guidance from your Linux distribution and
    processor vendor.

To see the other possible values for
/sys/devices/system/cpu/vulnerabilities/mds, refer to the
MDS
system information
section in Linux kernel’s documentation for
MDS.

On the host, validate that KVM is capable of exposing the
md-clear flag to guests:

# virsh domcapabilities kvm | grep md-clear
<feature policy='require' name='md-clear'/>

More information can be found on the ‘Diagnosis’ tab of this
security notice document
.

Performance Impact

Refer to this section titled “Performance Impact and Disabling MDS”
from this
security notice document
, under the Resolve tab.

Note

Although the article referred to is from Red Hat, the findings and
recommendations about performance impact apply for other distributions
also.

taikun-logo-icon

Explore Taikun CloudWorks in 2 Minutes!